logo
Davidoff
logo
  • Home
  • Cigar Reviews
    Cigar Reviews

    Blind, honest cigar reviews.

    91%
    Very Good

    Don Doroteo Salt of the Earth Piedra Viva Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

    93%
    Great

    Te Amo The Original San Andrés Valley Cigar Toro – Blind Cigar Review

    91%
    Very Good
    Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro - Blind Cigar Review

    Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

    • All Blind Reviews – Big Sortable List
    • Recent Blind Cigar Reviews
    • Quick Cigar Reviews
      • Recent Quick Cigar Reviews
      • Quick Review Archive
    • Accessory Reviews
      • Recent Accessory Reviews
      • Accessory Review Archive
    • Video Reviews
  • Cigars By Category
    • By Blender
      • AJ Fernandez
      • Andre Farkas
      • Carlos Fuente Jr
      • Christian Eiroa
      • Dion Giolito
      • Don Pepin Garcia
      • E.P. Carrillo
      • Jon Huber
      • Jonathan Drew
      • Jorge Padron
      • Nestor Plasencia
      • Nicholas Melillo
      • Pete Johnson
      • Rafael Nodal
      • Skip Martin
      • Steve Saka
      • Willy Herrera
    • By Brand
      • Alec Bradley
      • Arturo Fuente
      • C.L.E.
      • Camacho
      • Crowned Heads
      • Drew Estate
      • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
      • Espinosa
      • Illusione
      • Joya De Nicaragua
      • La Aurora
      • La Flor Dominicana
      • Liga Privada
      • My Father
      • Oliva
      • Padilla
      • Rocky Patel
      • RoMa Craft
    • By Panelist
      • Alan
      • Allison T.
      • Diana
      • Doug S.
      • Eric
      • Estevan Z.
      • Isaac M.
      • Jake P.
      • James H.
      • Jason H.
      • Jeb S.
      • Jeff
      • Jeremey W.
      • John A.
      • John I.
      • Joseph S.
      • Kevin A.
      • Kevin J.
      • Matt Cade
      • Mickey T.
      • Ryan H.
      • Sean F.
      • Steve
    • By Vitola (Size)
      • Belicoso
      • Churchill
      • Corona
      • Corona Gorda
      • Double Corona
      • Double Robusto
      • Double Toro
      • Figurado
      • Lancero
      • Lonsdale
      • Ninfa
      • Perfecto
      • Petite Corona
      • Petite Lancero
      • Robusto
      • Rothschild
      • Salomon
      • Toro
      • Torpedo
    • By Wrapper Type
      • Cameroon
      • Connecticut
      • Connecticut Broadleaf
      • Corojo
      • Criollo
      • Habano
      • Maduro
      • Mexican San Andres
      • Natural
      • Oscuro
      • Pennsylvania Broadleaf
      • Rosado
      • Shade Grown
      • Sumatra
      • Sun Grown
    • By Country
      • Costa Rica
      • Cuba
      • Dominican Republic
      • Honduras
      • Indonesia
      • Nicaragua
      • USA
  • News
    News

    Cigar news

    Black Label Trading Company shipping Bishops Blend to select retailers beginning this week

    Can you take a punch...Mr. Punch is on the scene!

    THE PUNCH-EST CIGAR EVER: MR. PUNCH BY PUNCH CIGARS – Can You Take A Punch??

    PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS TIM GRIEK AS VICE PRESIDENT OF SALES, EMEA & GLOBAL TRAVEL RETAIL

    • All News
    • PCA
    • Editorial
  • Tips and Tricks
    Tips and Tricks
    Tips & Tricks 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

    Tips & Tricks: 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

    Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

    Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

    Tips and Tricks: Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette

    Tips and Tricks: Who Brought This Guy? (Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette)

    • Tips and Tricks Archive
    • Recent Tips and Tricks
  • Top 25
    Top 25
    Top 25 Cigars of the Year - 2023

    Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2023

    Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

    Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

    Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

    Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

    • All
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2020
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2019
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2018
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2017
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2016
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year- 2015
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2014
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2013
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • The Blind Man’s Puff Crew
    • How This all Works…The Blind Man’s Puff Method
    • Privacy Policy
    • Admin
  • See all results
Random
  • Latest
  • Oldest
  • Random
  • A to Z

Allison T.

92%
Great
Blind Cigar Review: Micallef | Grande Bold Ligero 554L
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsFeaturedIPCPRMicallefNaturalNicaraguaSumatraToro
·August 19, 2020

Blind Cigar Review: Micallef | Grande Bold Ligero 554L

"Though this cigar was very one dimensional, in my opinion, it was well worth the investment of time. It would pair perfectly with an amaretto heavy cocktail or some fresh almond pastry. If you are a fan of medium body cigars with wonderful construction then this would be the cigar for you. Grab one and give it a shot." -Estevan Z. (TheRealBanzi)
Read More
88%
Good
Protocol Blue Gordo - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsCubariquenoDouble ToroFeaturedHabanoHector Alfonso Sr.MaduroNicaraguaOscuroPCA
·December 31, 2021

Protocol Blue Gordo – Blind Cigar Review

"This was a much larger cigar than I normally like to smoke. However, I went into it very open-mindedly and found the flavor notes in the first third and partway through the second third to be very good with lots of spiciness. I liked the mix of earthiness mixed with the spice and was looking forward to how the cigar progressed. Withdraw problems leading to burn issues, I truly lost interest halfway through the second third. I muddled my way through the rest of the cigar hoping that that full flavor from the beginning of the cigar would re-emerge. I would try the cigar again, but it definitely would suit me in a smaller vitola." -Diana (ArmyRN)
Read More
88%
Good
Punch 180 Aniversario - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsDouble CoronaFeaturedHondurasPunch
·April 22, 2022

Punch 180 Aniversario – Blind Cigar Review

"I don't usually go for the bigger cigars but this was excellent start to finish. The sweet cocoa at the beginning that morphed into buttered toast and warm cinnamon at the midway point was perfectly balanced by charred oak and black pepper on the retro. The final inch or so got a little heavy on the wood notes but I would definitely smoke this one again after a big dinner with a nice rye to pair." -Vance T. (Vance)
Read More
92%
Great
Blind Cigar Review: Vallorani | Trump 2020
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsChurchillFeaturedMaduroMexican San AndresNicaragua
·July 6, 2020

Blind Cigar Review: Vallorani | Trump 2020 Churchill

"This to me was just a fantastic smoke. Super rich and chewy all the way to the end. The musty tobacco aroma played nice with the beginning flavors from the cigar. It just felt right in your hand. The roasted flavors mixed with the chocolate and molasses was amazing." -Jake P. (Jake P.)
Read More
93%
Great
Blind Cigar Review: Hiram & Solomon | Shriner Toro
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsFeaturedHiram and SolomonNaturalNicaraguaSumatraToro
·February 21, 2020

Blind Cigar Review: Hiram & Solomon | Shriner Toro

"Though this cigar lacked body, in my opinion, I can not overstate how good this cigar was. I could see some people calling it one dimensional but in all honesty this cigar was a flavor bomb. Forgoing strength and body for the benefit of making a more flavorful blend. This cigar is perfect for anyone looking to expand their palate away from the light body, airy, cigars of the world. Pick one up and decided for yourself." -Estevan Z. (TheRealBanzi)
Read More
90%
Very Good
ATL Libertad Toro - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsEduardo FernandezFeatured
·December 10, 2021

ATL Libertad Toro – Blind Cigar Review

"This was not initially a cigar I would pick out to smoke. The ring gauge was great but the length of the cigar was more than I usually like. The cigar proved to be a flavor bomb for me and along with a great appearance provided a very good smoking experience. The first two-thirds were fantastic and even though the last third dropped off a bit more than I would have preferred, I enjoyed the cigar overall. Take a couple of inches off and make this a shorter toro and I’m in over and over again. " -Diana (ArmyRN)
Read More
91%
Very Good
Blind Cigar Review: Espinosa | Laranja Reserva Escuro Toro
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsBrazilian Mata FinaErik EspinosaEspinosaFeaturedHector Alfonso Sr.NicaraguaToro
·January 27, 2020

Blind Cigar Review: Espinosa | Laranja Reserva Escuro Toro

"The first two third ebbed and flowed with that savory meat and cappuccino creaminess and finally a dry cedar but I think the last third really takes a bunch away from the overall smoking experience. I feel like this cigar was made to experience with great friend and even better conversations. Making it a good everyday smoke." -Estevan Z. (TheRealBanzi)
Read More
89%
Good
Davidoff JR 50th Anniversary - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsDavidoffDominican RepublicEladio DiazFeaturedNaturalToro
·August 20, 2021

Davidoff JR 50th Anniversary – Blind Cigar Review

"What started out as a phenomenal cigar faded quickly to bitter then harsh. There was such a great sweetness and fruit profile at the beginning I settled in to what I thought was going to be an epic cigar. Instead, the cigar turned dry and earthy with heavy ground coffee and wood notes on the finish. I will be curious to find out what this cigar is and determine if I just got the "one off" from the floor that was just not great, or if this is a common profile of the cigar." -Kevin A. (Kevin A.)
Read More
89%
Good
RoMa Craft CRAFT 2021 - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsConnecticut BroadleafFeaturedPerfectoRoMa CraftSkip Martin
·February 18, 2022

RoMa Craft CRAFT 2021 – Blind Cigar Review

"Let me start off by referring to my statement about being glad I had a good meal beforehand. This couldn't have been any more true here, as this cigar really builds up and leaves it all on the table. Definitely not a cigar for the faint of heart, but a very rewarding cigar nonetheless. You can't go wrong with notes like charred meats and red pepper, and then coffee and chocolate. I'd have no problem smoking this again, but would save it for a time I could really enjoy its nuances. I paired it with water to ensure I could pick up all the notes, but could easily recommend pairing it with a solid pour of bourbon to really ratchet up the chocolate note. " -Doug S. (Unpossible_1)
Read More
88%
Good
Protocol Pool Party Year 2 - Blind Cigar Review
AllBlind Cigar ReviewsConnecticutCubariquenoErik EspinosaFeaturedHector Alfonso Sr.Mexican San AndresNicaragua
·August 18, 2021

Protocol Pool Party Year 2 – Blind Cigar Review

"This was likely the most challenging overall rating I've had to give since joining the team. The middle third was simply one of the best 30 minutes of cigar I've smoked this year. The unique, potent, balanced flavors were playing in perfect harmony and every puff somehow seemed to improve upon its predecessor. Unfortunately the first and final third underwhelmed. They certainly weren't bad, just subtle to the point of unnoticeable. So, would I smoke this again? 100% yes. In fact I'm dying to know: was the middle third an anomaly? Was the burn line issue a one-off? If there's even the slimmest chance I could experience, for a full 90 minutes, what I experienced at the halfway transition mark, I'd dedicate an entire shelf in my cabinet to these beauties." -Vance T. (Vance)
Read More
Load More
Davidoff

Recent Articles

Black Label Trading Company shipping Bishops Blend to select retailers beginning this week

Can you take a punch...Mr. Punch is on the scene!

THE PUNCH-EST CIGAR EVER: MR. PUNCH BY PUNCH CIGARS – Can You Take A Punch??

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS TIM GRIEK AS VICE PRESIDENT OF SALES, EMEA & GLOBAL TRAVEL RETAIL

Warped Selección Domain 4546 – Quick Cigar Review (Revisited)

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS RODRIGO MEDINA MENDIETA AS FIRST-EVER GLOBAL BRAND AMBASSADOR

Drop
JR Cigar
Cigar and Pipes
Casa de Montecristo
Drop
Boveda
logo
Copyright Blind Man's Puff 2022
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • Search
  • Home
  • Cigar Reviews
    • All Blind Reviews – Big Sortable List
    • Recent Blind Cigar Reviews
    • Quick Cigar Reviews
      • Recent Quick Cigar Reviews
      • Quick Review Archive
    • Accessory Reviews
      • Recent Accessory Reviews
      • Accessory Review Archive
    • Video Reviews
  • Cigars By Category
    • By Blender
      • AJ Fernandez
      • Andre Farkas
      • Carlos Fuente Jr
      • Christian Eiroa
      • Dion Giolito
      • Don Pepin Garcia
      • E.P. Carrillo
      • Jon Huber
      • Jonathan Drew
      • Jorge Padron
      • Nestor Plasencia
      • Nicholas Melillo
      • Pete Johnson
      • Rafael Nodal
      • Skip Martin
      • Steve Saka
      • Willy Herrera
    • By Brand
      • Alec Bradley
      • Arturo Fuente
      • C.L.E.
      • Camacho
      • Crowned Heads
      • Drew Estate
      • Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust
      • Espinosa
      • Illusione
      • Joya De Nicaragua
      • La Aurora
      • La Flor Dominicana
      • Liga Privada
      • My Father
      • Oliva
      • Padilla
      • Rocky Patel
      • RoMa Craft
    • By Panelist
      • Alan
      • Allison T.
      • Diana
      • Doug S.
      • Eric
      • Estevan Z.
      • Isaac M.
      • Jake P.
      • James H.
      • Jason H.
      • Jeb S.
      • Jeff
      • Jeremey W.
      • John A.
      • John I.
      • Joseph S.
      • Kevin A.
      • Kevin J.
      • Matt Cade
      • Mickey T.
      • Ryan H.
      • Sean F.
      • Steve
    • By Vitola (Size)
      • Belicoso
      • Churchill
      • Corona
      • Corona Gorda
      • Double Corona
      • Double Robusto
      • Double Toro
      • Figurado
      • Lancero
      • Lonsdale
      • Ninfa
      • Perfecto
      • Petite Corona
      • Petite Lancero
      • Robusto
      • Rothschild
      • Salomon
      • Toro
      • Torpedo
    • By Wrapper Type
      • Cameroon
      • Connecticut
      • Connecticut Broadleaf
      • Corojo
      • Criollo
      • Habano
      • Maduro
      • Mexican San Andres
      • Natural
      • Oscuro
      • Pennsylvania Broadleaf
      • Rosado
      • Shade Grown
      • Sumatra
      • Sun Grown
    • By Country
      • Costa Rica
      • Cuba
      • Dominican Republic
      • Honduras
      • Indonesia
      • Nicaragua
      • USA
  • News
    • All News
    • PCA
    • Editorial
  • Tips and Tricks
    • Tips and Tricks Archive
    • Recent Tips and Tricks
  • Top 25
    • All
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2020
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2019
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2018
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2017
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2016
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year- 2015
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2014
    • Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2013
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • The Blind Man’s Puff Crew
    • How This all Works…The Blind Man’s Puff Method
    • Privacy Policy
    • Admin
Start typing to see results or hit ESC to close
Nicaragua Toro Dominican Republic Robusto IPCPR
See all results

Email Signup