Random

Blind Cigar Reviews

Blind, honest cigar reviews.

92%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Drew Estate | Undercrown Dogma

All Blind Cigar Reviews Featured IPCPR Nicaragua

·December 20, 2019

Blind Cigar Review: Drew Estate | Undercrown Dogma

"This cigar started off with great flavors, but they were heavily muted and concerned me. Second third proved my patience worth the wait, with incredible flavor. Wasn't the most complex experience, but it was an immensely enjoyable cigar that I would really like to get my hands on more of. I was almost sad when I got down to the nub." -Doug S. (Unpossible_1)

90%

Very Good

All Blind Cigar Reviews Connecticut Dominican Republic Featured Gurkha Lonsdale

·February 24, 2023

Gurkha Collection Especial Lonsdale – Blind Cigar Review

"This was a splendid and sagacious cigar, with notes including honey graham cracker and rich baking spice, all of which I really enjoy. That being said, the open draw and feint ending were a bit of a downer for me. Overall, it is one I could see myself revisiting, as these drawbacks could be one-off issues and the next experience is much more fulfilling. " -Doug S. (Unpossible_1)

88%

Good

Drew Estate Herrera Esteli Miami Piramide Fino

All Blind Cigar Reviews Drew Estate Featured Habano Natural Torpedo USA Willy Herrera

·August 2, 2021

Drew Estate Herrera Esteli Miami Piramide Fino – Blind Cigar Review

"I liked this cigar and wanted to like it a whole lot more except for the burn issues and the falling off of flavors in the last third. I liked the look of it and the notes of leather, coffee, and salt are definitely flavor notes that I thoroughly enjoy. I’d definitely revisit this cigar again and might enjoy it with a mild Bloody Mary as I think it would enhance the flavors." -Diana (ArmyRN)

92%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Foundation | Charter Oak Habano Lonsdale

All Blind Cigar Reviews Export Featured Foundation Cigar Habano Lonsdale Natural Nicaragua Nicholas Melillo

·January 25, 2021

Blind Cigar Review: Foundation | Charter Oak Habano Lonsdale

"Solid mild to medium cigar. The spice and pepper on the front and end of the cigar were nice. With the middle, a tad more mild and less pepper and more earth and coffee it did not overwhelm you like som peppery cigar will to some people. This should be a cigar to try on many people's list. " -Jake P. (Jake P.)

93%

Great

CAO Cameroon L’Anniversaire Robusto - Blind Cigar Review

All Blind Cigar Reviews Cameroon CAO Featured Nicaragua Robusto

·February 28, 2024

CAO Cameroon L’Anniversaire Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

"Some days are just better than others, and this was one of those days. Beautiful weather paired with good company and capped with a superior cigar make this a day to remember. I honestly can’t remember a cigar with such luxurious smoke. And the light pepper and baking spices on my palate were interesting and welcome. This one is highly recommended!" -Jason H. (Jokey Smurf)

90%

Total Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: La Tribu | Gran Corona

All Blind Cigar Reviews Featured

·April 24, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: La Tribu | Gran Corona

"I really enjoyed this cigar and I think most cigar folks will too. It was a medium-full strength experience and while the transitions were not ground breaking they were very good. This cigar tasted like a cigar; and what I mean by that is it had a very traditional profile with the earth, leather, oak, cedar and lets not forget various peppers. It never required a touch-up even though the burn at times was not pretty. This cigar definitely has the potential to make it into my regular rotation and I wouldn't hand it out to my mooching friends as I would want them all to myself." -Matt C. (Big Matt)

91%

Very Good

All Blind Cigar Reviews Drew Estate Featured Herrera Esteli Jonathan Drew Mexican San Andres Toro USA Willy Herrera

·November 4, 2022

Drew Estate Herrera Estelí Miami The Raji – Blind Cigar Review

"Smooth and perfectly balanced was the name of the game for this cigar from beginning to end. The transitions in flavor profiles were subtle yet plentiful enough to keep my palate engaged while the contrast of bitter and sweet complimented each other in such harmony that was not overly complex or obscure. Every puff was thoroughly enjoyable and even though it was almost a two-hour smoke, I didn't want it to end." -Noah S. (Noah)

89%

Total Score - Good

Blind Cigar Review: La Flor Dominicana | Reserva Especial Robusto

All Blind Cigar Reviews Connecticut Dominican Republic Eric Featured IPCPR Isaac M.Jason H.Jeff R.La Flor Dominicana Litto Gomez Natural Robusto

·December 28, 2016

Blind Cigar Review: La Flor Dominicana | Reserva Especial Belicoso

“I’ll start off by stating that I am not a fan of mild cigars…They generally just don’t keep my attention. This was an exception. The occasional flavor transitions, plus the excellent initial flavors were interesting and worthy of my time. This is something that I would highly recommend to any new smoker, of someone looking for a change of pace. Also, a perfect way to start a day. The reveal of this one will be interesting…. This cigar is one where the totality of the experience is greater than each of it’s parts…well done.” –Jason H. (Jokey Smurf)

90%

Total Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Fable | Fourth Prime Doc

All Blind Cigar Reviews Eric Fable Featured Gregg IPCPR Isaac M.Jason H.Jeff R.Maduro Mitul Shah Nicaragua Pennsylvania Broadleaf Robusto

·January 9, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Fable | Fourth Prime Doc

“This cigar, based on looks alone, was one that I was anticipating. The best part is that it didn’t disappoint. Fuller flavored. Fuller bodied. Just what I was expecting. The flavor of this cigar was spot on, for me, to the point that I was easily able to forgive the burn problems. I found that this cigar lighted to be smoked, and not set down to rest, which was fine because I didn’t want to put it down.” –Isaac M. (The Nothing)

88%

Total Score - Good

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Therapy Connecticut Toro

All Blind Cigar Reviews Connecticut Craig Featured Fred Rewey Matthew T.Natural Nicaragua Nomad Sandeep Steve Toro

·September 26, 2016

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Therapy Connecticut Toro

"If this cigar had captured the final 3rd throughout it would have been great, unfortunately, there was too much chemical flavor during the first two 3rds to reccomend this cigar to anyone." -Craig (WyldKnyght)

Don Doroteo Salt of the Earth Piedra Viva Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Te Amo The Original San Andrés Valley Cigar Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

THE PUNCH-EST CIGAR EVER: MR. PUNCH BY PUNCH CIGARS – Can You Take A Punch??

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS TIM GRIEK AS VICE PRESIDENT OF SALES, EMEA & GLOBAL TRAVEL RETAIL

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS RODRIGO MEDINA MENDIETA AS FIRST-EVER GLOBAL BRAND AMBASSADOR

Tips & Tricks: 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

Tips and Tricks: Who Brought This Guy? (Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette)

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2023

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

Blind Cigar Reviews

Blind Cigar Review: Drew Estate | Undercrown Dogma

Gurkha Collection Especial Lonsdale – Blind Cigar Review

Drew Estate Herrera Esteli Miami Piramide Fino – Blind Cigar Review

Blind Cigar Review: Foundation | Charter Oak Habano Lonsdale

CAO Cameroon L’Anniversaire Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Blind Cigar Review: La Tribu | Gran Corona

Drew Estate Herrera Estelí Miami The Raji – Blind Cigar Review

Blind Cigar Review: La Flor Dominicana | Reserva Especial Belicoso

Blind Cigar Review: Fable | Fourth Prime Doc

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Therapy Connecticut Toro

THE PUNCH-EST CIGAR EVER: MR. PUNCH BY PUNCH CIGARS – Can You Take A Punch??

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS TIM GRIEK AS VICE PRESIDENT OF SALES, EMEA & GLOBAL TRAVEL RETAIL

Warped Selección Domain 4546 – Quick Cigar Review (Revisited)

PLASENCIA CIGARS APPOINTS RODRIGO MEDINA MENDIETA AS FIRST-EVER GLOBAL BRAND AMBASSADOR

CAO BRINGS BACK AMAZON BASIN DAGGERS FOR LIMITED 2026 RUN

Email Signup