Oldest

John I.

89%

Good

Blind Cigar Review: Monte by Montecristo | AJ Fernandez Belicoso

AJ Fernandez All Belicoso Blind Cigar Reviews Featured Habano John I.Matthew T.Natural Nicaragua Steve Zane G.

·October 5, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Monte by Montecristo | AJ Fernandez Belicoso

"This was a good looking cigar that was enjoyable for the first two thirds. The final third fell a bit short as the cigar got hot and bitter. Would be interested too see what some age does to these. " -Zane G. (Zane)

90%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Hoyo | La Amistad Silver Robusto

AJ Fernandez All Blind Cigar Reviews Featured Habano Hoyo de Monterrey (DR)IPCPR John I.Matthew T.Natural Nicaragua Robusto Ryan Steve Zane G.

·October 30, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Hoyo | La Amistad Silver Robusto

"I was a little concerned on the cold draw before lighting, but this cigar was really pretty good. Good flavor combinations, and lots of smoke output. It did burn a bit on the fast side, but the flavors that came throughout the smoking experience were tasty and made sense together. I would smoke this again." -Matthew T. (A Huge Nerd)

91%

Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Espinosa | Murcielago Robusto

All Blind Cigar Reviews Dave Erik Espinosa Espinosa Featured IPCPR John I.Maduro Matthew T.Mexican San Andres Nicaragua Robusto Ryan

·November 15, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Espinosa | Murcielago Robusto

"This was a pretty long smoke for a robusto, taking almost an hour and a half to complete. I enjoyed this one a lot and intentionally smoked it slow and cool. Very nice flavors and great performance. I'll be seeking this one out again for sure. " -Dave W. (mdwest)

89%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Partagas | Ramon y Ramon Robusto

All Blind Cigar Reviews Cameroon Dave Dominican Republic Featured IPCPR Jhonys Diaz John I.Matthew T.Natural Partagas (DR)Robusto Ryan Zane G.

·December 8, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Partagas | Ramon y Ramon Robusto

"I enjoyed the flavors of this stick, however the lack of complexity and changes made for a monotone experience. Go ahead and give it a try... it is good, but I would like something more arousing. " -John A. (John A.)

90%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton T&T | Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

Alan All Blind Cigar Reviews Dave Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Featured Habano John I.Matthew T.Natural Nicaragua Steve Saka Toro

·January 19, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton T&T | Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

"Overall a very pleasant stick. Once it started mellowing out a little bit the cigar became a very nice smoke. This is one I'll be looking at more closely after the reveal, and would consider a box purchase on if the price is right. " -Dave W. (mdwest)

93%

Overall Score

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton Tobaco & Trust | Umbagog Robusto PlusBlind Cigar Review: Dunbarton Tobaco & Trust | Umbagog Robusto Plus

All Ashley C.Blind Cigar Reviews Connecticut Broadleaf Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Featured IPCPR Jason H.John I.Maduro Matthew T.Nicaragua Robusto Steve Saka

·October 20, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton Tobaco & Trust | Umbagog Robusto Plus

"This was a cigar that fired on all cylinders for me. Once I paired it with a very rich stout, it really came into its own and was a superb cap to my evening. I have absolutely nothing to criticize with this sample. It would be my honor to personally thank the blender and roller of this super premium cigar. This will find a home in my rotation if I can find more!" -Jason H. (Jokey Smurf)

88%

Overall Score - Good

Blind Cigar Review: CAO | Amazon Anaconda

All Blind Cigar Reviews CAO Dave Featured Habano IPCPR John I.Matthew T.Natural Nicaragua Rick Rodriguez Ryan Toro Zane G.

·November 3, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: CAO | Amazon Anaconda

"Long story short, it was OK. Short story not so short, the first two thirds were tasty, and seemed to be cohesive. The final third just failed in my estimation. The flavors were unpleasant and harsh. If this cigar could have continued the same flavor profile, I would have rated it much higher. " -Matthew T. (A Huge Nerd)

91%

Overall Score - Very Good

Adam B.AJ Fernandez All Blind Cigar Reviews Diesel Featured Habano IPCPR John I.Nicaragua Robusto Stefan Steve Zane G.

·December 6, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Diesel | Grind (2017) Robusto

"Pretty solid effort. A really darkly attractive cigar with big rich flavors in the earthy/woody range with some interesting side notes of herbs and spices coming in at a few points. I'd love to stick a box of these in the back of my cabinet and forget about them for a year or two. I'll bet they really sing with a little age. " -John I. (John I.)

91%

Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2013

All Blind Cigar Reviews Davidoff Dominican Republic Eladio Diaz Featured Habano Isaac M.John I.Matthew T.Natural Stefan Toro

·January 8, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2013

"This cigar was a tasty bugger. The performance throughout the smoking experience, coupled with great flavors and combinations was just great. The sweetness mixed with other nuances really made me happy, and I will be looking forward to knowing what this is so I can buy some for myself. Well done! " -Matthew T. (A Huge Nerd)

90%

Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Fin de los Mundos Toro

Alan All Blind Cigar Reviews Dave Featured Fred Rewey IPCPR Isaac M.John I.Nicaragua Nomad Pennsylvania Broadleaf Toro

·February 23, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Fin de los Mundos Toro

"Man, this was a fun cigar. I have to blame myself for the performance at the beginning, even if it did feel and look ok. Once I gave it the deeper cut, this cigar was awesome. The savory flavors kept me attached the whole way through. There was a lot more complexity in the first third that seemed to tone down through the rest of the cigar; I really wish it just kept going. " -Isaac M. (The Nothing)

CAO BX3 Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Sindicato Artista Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Macanudo 1968 Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Crowned Heads Announces Las Calaveras 2023 – Cigar News

Atabey Black Moves from NFT to Real World – Cigar News

Micallef Adds Toro and Robusto Sizes to Leyenda – Cigar News

Tips & Tricks: 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

Tips and Tricks: Who Brought This Guy? (Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette)

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2020

John I.

Blind Cigar Review: Monte by Montecristo | AJ Fernandez Belicoso

Blind Cigar Review: Hoyo | La Amistad Silver Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Espinosa | Murcielago Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Partagas | Ramon y Ramon Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton T&T | Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

Blind Cigar Review: Dunbarton Tobaco & Trust | Umbagog Robusto Plus

Blind Cigar Review: CAO | Amazon Anaconda

Blind Cigar Review: Diesel | Grind (2017) Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2013

Blind Cigar Review: Nomad | Fin de los Mundos Toro

CAO BX3 Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Crowned Heads Announces Las Calaveras 2023 – Cigar News

Sindicato Artista Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Macanudo 1968 Robusto – Blind Cigar Review

Atabey Black Moves from NFT to Real World – Cigar News

Email Signup