Top Rated

Isaac M.

95%

Excellent

CAO Arcana Mortal Coil - Blind Cigar Review

Adam B.All Blind Cigar Reviews CAO Connecticut Broadleaf Featured Isaac M.Jason H.John I.Nicaragua Rick Rodriguez Toro

·July 26, 2021

CAO Arcana Mortal Coil – Blind Cigar Review

"Holy hell, three hours to smoke a Toro? Sure was! And it was a great one at that. It had great flavors, good transitions, and kept my interest going, somehow, for that long. The entirety of this cigar is better than its components. Each third, when broken down, doesn't score as well to me as the entire experience. This isn't a cigar I could smoke on a daily basis because, frankly, I don't have three hours every day to enjoy a cigar. However when I find such occasion you bet I will fire this one up again. " -Isaac M. (The Nothing)

93%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Diademas Finas

All Blind Cigar Reviews Davidoff Dominican Republic Featured Habano Hendrik Kelner Isaac M.John A.Mickey T.Natural Ryan H.

·September 26, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Diademas Finas

"You ever anticipate smoking a cigar, and when you finally get the chance to smoke it it just meets all your expectations? Well that was this cigar for me. I smoked, and performed beautifully. It was exactly what I needed at the time. the cigar was very smooth, and elegant. There was lots of cream, some cinnamon and citrus flavors to hold my attention. I want, no NEED more of these. " -Mickey T. (irratebass)

93%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: San Pedro De Macoris | Brazil Robusto

All Blind Cigar Reviews Brazilian Daniel S.Diana Dominican Republic Featured Isaac M.Jason H.Kevin J.Robusto Royal Agio Cigars

·June 5, 2019

Blind Cigar Review: San Pedro De Macoris | Brazil Robusto

"Would I buy a box of these? Absolutely. Flavors were right in my wheelhouse. Very enjoyable. Will be on the lookout for more. " -Kevin J. (maninblack77)

93%

Overall Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Black Label Trading Company | Bishop's Blend Corona Larga

All Black Label Trading Company Blind Cigar Reviews Eric Featured IPCPR Isaac M.James Brown Jason H.John I.Nicaragua

·July 25, 2017

Blind Cigar Review: Black Label Trading Company | Bishop’s Blend Corona Larga

"This cigar was, well, outstanding to me. This is something I could enjoy at any time and could even be something that I'd smoke very regularly. The flavors caught my attention at the beginning and the constant evolution kept me coming back for more. It was a surprisingly long smoking cigar with made it that much better." -Isaac M. (The Nothing)

92%

Overall Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Southern Draw | Jacobs Ladder Robusto

Alan All Blind Cigar Reviews Dave Featured IPCPR Isaac M.John I.Maduro Nicaragua Pennsylvania Broadleaf Robert Holt Robusto Southern Draw Stefan

·March 2, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Southern Draw | Jacobs Ladder Robusto

"Really impressive cigar, the initial blast of flavor was exceptional. The sweetness toward the middle became a little bit monotonous, but the deep rich flavors throughout the final were excellent." -John I. (John I.)

94%

Overall Score - Excellent

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2011

All Blind Cigar Reviews Daniel S.Davidoff Diana Dominican Republic Eladio Diaz Featured Habano Hendrik Kelner Isaac M.John I.Natural Toro Wes

·April 6, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2011

"Great smoke. Amazing construction which has definitely contributed to the experience. Deep rich leather and nuttiness on bold display here. It's a flavor profile that I enjoyed a lot although there wasn't a lot of transitional stuff going on. I'd be happy to smoke these by the truckload, and I'd nub them every time. " -John I. (John I.)

93%

Overall Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Iconic Leaf | Recluse Amadeus Habano Reserva Lancero

Alan All Blind Cigar Reviews Daniel S.Dominican Republic Emmett Featured Habano Iconic Leaf Isaac M.John I.Lancero Natural

·September 28, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Iconic Leaf | Recluse Amadeus Habano Reserva Lancero

"If I were to make my own cigar, it would look much like this. It was almost painful to put this cigar down. The savory qualities kept me coming back to it, distracting me from other things (like the kiddo crying about her ball rolling into the street.) It wouldn't be hard to put this cigar into regular rotation, and when this is posted, I'll probably find a box. While there wasn't a whole lot of transition in flavors, what flavors it has keeps you coming back for more." -Isaac M. (The Nothing)

93%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Joya de Nicaragua | Número Uno

Alan Alejandro Martinez Cuenca All Blind Cigar Reviews Connecticut Featured IPCPR Isaac M.John A.Joya De Nicaragua Juan Martinez Lonsdale Mickey T.Natural Nicaragua Ryan H.

·August 9, 2019

Blind Cigar Review: Joya de Nicaragua | Número Uno

"Wow, this is world class stick. Never have I had such a well balanced, nuanced, medium bodied smoke. The three transitions provided a ménage à trois of deliciousness that would satisfy any hardened and seasoned cigar smoker. I am floored by the quality of this cigar. BOX WORTHY. " -John A. (Bostoneo)

93%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Black Works Studio | Boondock Saint Corona Larga

All Black Label Trading Company Blind Cigar Reviews Blk Wks Corona Gorda Daniel S.Featured Isaac M.James Brown John I.Matthew T.Nicaragua Pennsylvania Broadleaf

·February 28, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Black Works Studio | Boondock Saint Corona Larga

"It's hard for me to assign a top rating to any cigar, and I try to reserve the highest mark for something really wondrous. This is about as close to cigar perfection for me as I can imagine. Big bold flavors with a lot of strength. Packs a punch but the potency was never over the top and the overall balance between strength and flavor was really thoroughly impressive. " -John I. (John I.)

92%

Total Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Warped | Maestro del Tiempo 5205

All Blind Cigar Reviews Corojo Eric Featured IPCPR Isaac M.Jason H.Jeff R.Kyle Gellis Lonsdale Natural Nicaragua Warped

·December 13, 2016

Blind Cigar Review: Warped | Maestro del Tiempo 5205

“One word: Excellent. From its appearance, its aroma, its feel, the amount of smoke it produced, to its flavor profile…my palate went on a fun rollercoaster ride. I thoroughly enjoyed this blend. Whoever blended this cigar deserves a raise.” –Jeff R. (JR)

Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

West Tampa Tobacco Co. Circle of Life Toro (Pre Release) – Blind Cigar Review

Drew Estate Blackened S84 Toro – Blind Cigar Review

PCA 2024 – Live Coverage – Blind Man’s Puff

Artista Cigars Expands Offerings with New Lines at PCA – Cigar News

Luciano Cigars Partners with Ron Harper for “Underrated” Line – Cigar News

Tips & Tricks: 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

Tips and Tricks: Who Brought This Guy? (Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette)

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2023

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

Isaac M.

CAO Arcana Mortal Coil – Blind Cigar Review

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Diademas Finas

Blind Cigar Review: San Pedro De Macoris | Brazil Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Black Label Trading Company | Bishop’s Blend Corona Larga

Blind Cigar Review: Southern Draw | Jacobs Ladder Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2011

Blind Cigar Review: Iconic Leaf | Recluse Amadeus Habano Reserva Lancero

Blind Cigar Review: Joya de Nicaragua | Número Uno

Blind Cigar Review: Black Works Studio | Boondock Saint Corona Larga

Blind Cigar Review: Warped | Maestro del Tiempo 5205

Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

West Tampa Tobacco Co. Circle of Life Toro (Pre Release) – Blind Cigar Review

Drew Estate Blackened S84 Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Aganorsa Leaf Arsenio Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Lovely Cigars No. 162 Churchill – Blind Cigar Review

Email Signup