Oldest

John A.

91%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2008

All Blind Cigar Reviews David F.Davidoff Dominican Republic Eladio Diaz Featured Habano John A.Mickey T.Natural Ryan H.Steve Toro

·January 10, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2008

"This was a thoroughly enjoyable stick with its strong points being the first two thirds. Whoever blended this cigar meant to create something special with a very flavorful mix of tobaccos that pleased my pallete immensely. I can only hope the price point on this stick is reasonable so I can stock up!" -John A. (John A.)

89%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Home Roll | Brazilian Villain

All Blind Cigar Reviews Corona Gorda David F.Featured Habano Home Roll John A.Mickey T.Natural Ryan H.Steve USA

·January 31, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Home Roll | Brazilian Villain

"This was a nice mild to medium smoke, which only got into the straight medium in the final third. The cigar was very smooth with a small sweetness that held my attention that resembled marshmallow. I highly recommend this cigar as you first smoke of the day with morning coffee. I would like to smoke more of these." -Mickey T. (irratebass)

90%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | Imperia Islero Toro

All Blind Cigar Reviews David F.Dominican Republic Featured Habano Jason H.John A.Mickey T.MLB Cigar Ventures Natural Ryan H.Toro

·April 11, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | Imperia Islero Toro

"This was overall a pleasant medium bodied smoke with a few transitions throughout. The profile was limited to a few flavors which I had hoped that it would be more diverse. Overall a good smoke to enjoy and relax with. " -John A. (John A.)

92%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | David P. Ehrlich Tremont Toro

All Blind Cigar Reviews David F.Jason H.John A.Mickey T.MLB Cigar Ventures Ryan H.

·May 9, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | David P. Ehrlich Tremont Toro

"This was a really nice cigar. Definitely a fist cigar of the day while sitting out on your deck with your morning coffee as the sun rises up. There was plenty of walnut flavors and just a touch of spice and black pepper. I would say this was a mild to medium plus cigar, and there was just enough sweetness that kept popping up and wasn't in your face. " -Mickey T. (irratebass)

93%

Great

Blind Cigar Review: Providencia | Trinitas

All Blind Cigar Reviews David F.Dominican Republic Featured IPCPR Jason H.John A.Mickey T.Perfecto Providencia Ryan H.

·June 1, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Providencia | Trinitas

"This was real joy to smoke. I wouldn't have minded a bit more flavor variety but that's just shooting for the moon... The flavors that were present were delightful and kept me puffing! This one is purchase worthy for sure." -Jason H. (Jokey Smurf)

88%

Overall Score - Good

Blind Cigar Review: Emilio | LJZ Robusto

All Blind Cigar Reviews David F.Emilio Cigars Featured Habano IPCPR James Brown John A.Mickey T.Natural News Nicaragua Robusto Ryan H.Steve

·January 12, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Emilio | LJZ Robusto

"This cigar was mediocre in my opinion. There was not much complexity. Smooth notes of spice and hay were the cornerstones, but the char crept in and took over through the second and final third of the cigar. A little age might do this cigar some good, so do not give up entirely on this stick. It might grow into something very good." -Steve (ThaGreatWazoo)

92%

Overall Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Caldwell | Hit and Run Corona Gorda

All Blind Cigar Reviews Caldwell Corona Gorda David F.Dominican Republic Eric Featured Habano IPCPR John A.Matt Matt Booth Natural Robert Caldwell

·February 5, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Caldwell | Hit and Run Corona Gorda

"I was very surprised by this stick. After the light aromas on the prelight, the cigar was full of great flavors. It was very cubanesque from the look and vitola to the flavor. I would love to smoke this in the morning with a cup of coffee. The stick had a couple of faults but was easy to overlook because the flavor was so good. I even nubbed this thing all the way down." -Matt (Mattehh)

94%

Excellent

Blind Cigar Review: HVC | Pan Caliente Double Corona

All Blind Cigar Reviews Corona Gorda Criollo David F.Featured Honduras HVC Cigars IPCPR Jason H.John A.Mickey T.Natural Reiner Lorenzo Ryan H.

·April 25, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: HVC | Pan Caliente Double Corona

"I really enjoyed this cigar. So much sweet cream throughout with a great progression of spice building up. I was impressed by the appearance and smell even before lighting this cigar and it delivered a wonderful and relaxing experience. Would strongly recommend if the price allows. " -David F. (dfafjf)

91%

Overall Score - Very Good

Blind Cigar Review: Oliva | Gilberto Reserva Corona

All Blind Cigar Reviews Corona Featured Jason H.John A.Mickey T.Natural Nicaragua Oliva Ryan H.Sumatra

·May 18, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Oliva | Gilberto Reserva Corona

"This was a nice pleasant smoke that I would absolutely smoke again. I believe this was a corona or even a petite corona. There was plenty of transitions to keep my attention. Starting out with wood, chocolate and rye then switching up to earth tones then settling out with cream.....very interesting smoke. " -Mickey T. (irratebass)

92%

Overall Score - Great

Blind Cigar Review: Jenneff Cigars | Family Blend Perfecto

All Blind Cigar Reviews Brazilian Dave Dominican Republic Featured Jenneff Cigars John A.Matt Mickey T.Perfecto Ryan H.

·June 8, 2018

Blind Cigar Review: Jenneff Cigars | Family Blend Perfecto

"While things started out a little slow in the beginning with some harshness in the smoke, the cigar progressively improved with every inch and ended up being very enjoyable by the end. I would certainly smoke this one again, and would be happy to recommend it to friends. " -Dave W. (mdwest)

Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

West Tampa Tobacco Co. Circle of Life Toro (Pre Release) – Blind Cigar Review

Drew Estate Blackened S84 Toro – Blind Cigar Review

PCA 2024 – Live Coverage – Blind Man’s Puff

Artista Cigars Expands Offerings with New Lines at PCA – Cigar News

Luciano Cigars Partners with Ron Harper for “Underrated” Line – Cigar News

Tips & Tricks: 5 Cigar & Beer Pairings from a Cigar Smoker Who Prefers Lighter Brews

Tips and Tricks: Holiday 2016 Cigar Gift Guide

Tips and Tricks: Who Brought This Guy? (Cigar Store and Lounge Etiquette)

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2023

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2022

Top 25 Cigars of the Year – 2021

John A.

Blind Cigar Review: Davidoff | Master Selection 2008

Blind Cigar Review: Home Roll | Brazilian Villain

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | Imperia Islero Toro

Blind Cigar Review: MLB Cigar Ventures | David P. Ehrlich Tremont Toro

Blind Cigar Review: Providencia | Trinitas

Blind Cigar Review: Emilio | LJZ Robusto

Blind Cigar Review: Caldwell | Hit and Run Corona Gorda

Blind Cigar Review: HVC | Pan Caliente Double Corona

Blind Cigar Review: Oliva | Gilberto Reserva Corona

Blind Cigar Review: Jenneff Cigars | Family Blend Perfecto

Protocol Phoebe Couzins Maduro Toro – Blind Cigar Review

West Tampa Tobacco Co. Circle of Life Toro (Pre Release) – Blind Cigar Review

Drew Estate Blackened S84 Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Aganorsa Leaf Arsenio Toro – Blind Cigar Review

Lovely Cigars No. 162 Churchill – Blind Cigar Review

Email Signup